Since we got back from Japan, I've stalled a bit in the reading. My bookclub title is Hanya Yanagihara's other book, and is very long (28 hours on Audible). The first 10 hours is like a slow dull retelling of Washington Square in my head, so I was about to give it away when it finally got interesting about race and Hawaii. Then the book picked up and I'm almost at the end. It's interesting but I don't feel it's worth it. When a book is this long, the story really needs to be riveting, not a long rambling yarn. I feel like we are humouring the author, rather than the author entertaining us. It has some good bits, and I guess if you love her other book, A little life, you'll like this.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e1fe/4e1fe18cdf04cf6036168328eedd4563cf5eea8c" alt=""
This is my other bookclub title. It's a very bleak memoir but the simplicity of the writing makes very profound observations nailed down in a single sentence. Analysis of human behaviour and psychological truths are scattered throughout in a few words. The story is harsh and bleak. It's far form the comfortable middle class experience. I'm really enjoying it. I did feel almost guilty reading it on the beach - a polar opposite experience to the words and world I was immersed in. Tennessee Williams described it as
"a true document of human desperation, shattering in its impact".
A few people had reviewed it around the link ups so I decided to give it a go. It's fun and it had a few clever surprises for me. I might try another in the 'series' down the track. It's an easy, old fashioned mystery with a new style update, so to speak.
Linking with #WOYBS #Bookdate #TalkaboutitTuesday #SundaySalon #SundayPost #StackingtheShelves #AnythingGoes
Hello,
ReplyDeleteGreat reviews, I will add the mystery to my reading list.
Take care, have a great day!
Such great reviews. Gives me some ideas for my little free library. Also, do you do bookcrossing?
ReplyDeleteWhat is book crossing?
DeleteJust googled. No I don't but I walk past 2 street libraries daily on the dog walk and I leave my books on the fence for people to take when they walk past.
DeleteYes, though I find the topic of race and Hawaii interesting, 28 hours is a lot to invest in a book one doesn’t love. I looked up For Bread Alone and it does seem a bit bleak. However, I was struck by this part of your review, “..the simplicity of the writing makes very profound observations nailed down in a single sentence.” That alone convinced me to put it on my TBR. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteIt's really difficult subject matter but told in such a way i find it hard to judge and it makes me think a lot about things. My book group didn't feel the same. They seem hooked on just the story, so most didn't like it.
DeleteI have had A Little Life on both my physical bookshelf and my ebookshelf for many years, and I haven't gotten around to read it yet. Sigh.
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing For Bread Alone. I'm not in the mood right now for bleak, but it sounds like an excellent read nevertheless.
I borrowded the audio of everyone in my family has killed someone from my library. The reader is very good. I concur with your review it's a classic mystery w/a fresh update.
ReplyDeleteAll my freinds LOVED A Little Life but if it's like this one, I'll p0ass. It's not terrible but not worth the effort, or the length it takes becomes an irritant, rather than something to luxuriate in.
DeletePaddle Board - i def don't have the skills for surf board. Tho I watched the Eddy this year and my fb feed has become awash with brilliant surfing from around the world.
ReplyDeleteI listened to A Little Life and thought it was amazing so maybe I'd like To Paradise. I listened to Everyone In My Family Has Killed Someone and also the next one Everyone on This Train Is a Suspect (or something like that) on audio, and liked them both.
ReplyDeleteI'm reading a memoir by a local author that I know and it seems she grew up with an abusive mother, so it's tough to read.
I haven't been keeping up with everyone, so wondering how long you were in Japan, and was the beach there? Will look back through some past posts to see what I can find out! ;)
The beach was at a Sydney location only accessible by boat. We say there twice a year.
DeleteAlas Japan was only a 9 day trip...
DeleteOuch, that's a long book for a book club!
ReplyDeleteJill
https://www.allthebooksihaventread.com/