Don't get me wrong, I love being Australian. I love living here. I do love travel but I think this country is best suited to me and we are indeed very lucky (for the most part). However, I saw this on my travels and I can't get it out of my head. Where did we go so wrong?
In Japan, the houses are right on the footpath or road. No fence, no distance. They leave their bikes (or prams) out the front. The bikes have bags with presumably stuff in it. Or the prams have nappy bags underneath. The bikes aren't chained to anything.No one steals them. There is no presumption anyone would.
In Australia (and America), you can barely get a parcel left on your doorstep (which is a good walk away from the street) without someone nicking off with it. Where did we go wrong? What aren't we doing that created this difference?
My husband had his bike stolen with an angle
grinder cutting through the chain. The guy turned up almost immediately after my husband left work for the day. All caught on camera (and the person arrested) so there was no mistaking what went down.
I asked a FB group and one person said they'd studied this in Criminology and it was put down to the closed culture (homogenous race is linked to lower crime, but also they are raised to respect and honour others from an early age). Another (American) blamed high meth problems in our countries and thought you could only be crime free in a gated community (interestingly, Australians view gated communities quite differently, so that's a whole other cultural clash there). Another person asked if there were high punishments for crime, or was it out of politeness that people didn't steal?
I do not have the answer, but clearly we are doing something wrong as a society. I remember in France at Xmas time I pointed out to a local friend how amazed I was that the Christmas trees in the streets had decorations just hanging from the branches, all over Paris. He looked at me quizzically and said "They're decorations. Why would anyone steal them?" It was incomprehensible to him. I pointed out that in Australia, those decorations had to be wired into the tree, otherwise it would be stripped bare in minutes on the first Saturday night after the city had had a few drinks....That trip was also when there were bombings in Paris and I'd not registered I'd shown my bag to security on the way into the department store. On the way out, I walked over to Security so he could look inside my bag. He questioned "Why would I want to look into your bag when you leave?" I then realised he was looking for bombs, not shoplifters. I mumbled something about in Australia we check when you leave because we steal stuff...it was not my finest patriotic moment.
One of the hotels we stayed at, I paid in full on check in because I wanted to make a quick getaway in the morning. We are 4 people, 2 rooms so should we order in house or hit the mini bar, we could potentially rack up a large bill. I said "Here's the credit card for incidentals" (a different card). The clerk replied "Oh don't worry about that". Instantly, my first thought in my head was "Are you crazy? What if I'm a thief" I know that I am not and I still thought that. I clearly have a default expectation or wariness wired into my head from cultural experience (or newspaper brain washing). So am I seeing more petty crime in Australia than is there? (Are the gated communities in the US seeing danger outside their walls that is above the reality?).
So I ask you, what are we (quite a number of countries around the world, not just Australia and America) doing wrong? Why do we have a culture that assumes theft, that builds society with that expectation, and where it does happen frequently?
How can the Japanese just leave their bikes unlocked and they're still there in the morning?
Linking with #WWWhimsy #TalkaboutitTuesday
I think some cultures foster more loyalty to the group rather than to the individual. Americans and Australians tend to value individuality.
ReplyDeleteDon’t let the French fool you. They seem to think that stealing from tourists is justified. I stopped a man from stealing my purse on a subway in Paris, and several years later when I went back there, someone tried to rob my partner.
My husband lost his wallet full of money in Paris in the marathon. The organisers made everyone look for it and they found it - got it all back!! He had no French, either!
DeleteIt's so sad here in America. All those poor people in California and looters have started already. Crime in America is completely out of hand. I have no idea how to make things better. Seems like it starts with family teaching respect for all people. Just a thought.
ReplyDeleteI think it has to be something in upbringing but I also doubt many parents say "Oh it's okay to steal that if it's just on their doorstep" so I know it's clearly more complicated than that....
DeleteEileen, your comment is on the back end but not here -who knows why? ?? It is nice for them. I did ask my local friends if Japanese got ripped off when thy travelled because they didn't realise what went o in other cultures and he said yes, there were always warnings in the newspaper about it....
ReplyDelete...the world has too many greedy people.
ReplyDeleteI remember when I first moved to Australia and the security guard wanted to check my bags when I left the store, I was totally gobsmacked! I don't know the secret to Japan's success but I wish I did!
ReplyDeleteHi Lydia, it's a very sad reflection of our Australian culture isn't it? Just yesterday my husband arrived home after doing some grocery shopping. He was bringing the shopping in and had left the garage door open and the door into the house was unlocked. He was stuffing around inside not rushing to go back out. I had a bit of a spack attack telling him to get out there quickly and get that garage door shut or the car could be stolen or we could be victims of a home invasion. I am just wired to think that way now. Very sad! I'm not sure of the answer but I do know that the Japanese people do seem to far more disciplined and respectful of each other! Thanks for linking up with #WWWhimsy ! xo
ReplyDeleteI don't know if it's 'wired' or we've been hyper brainwashed our whole life to think like that. I don't know.
DeleteI sometimes despair, Lydia. I'm in a local community Facebook group and every day someone is posting about youths trying to break in, or stealing cars probably because they have no direction in life and too much time on their hands. I agree with you about Japan it was something I thought about when we travelled there. There is respect from a young age, children are taught to respect elders and others and it becomes a way of life. #TeamWWWhimsy x
ReplyDeleteThis is a very topical post Lydia and I'm afraid I don't have the answers either. I can say living in our small rural town we have quite a low crime rate and values still seem important. Very thought provoking post.
ReplyDeleteI do wonder how much is real and how much is perception. Though we have been broken into - hilariously we don't have much in the way of valuables so the most expensive claim on the insurance was the door they damaged when breaking the lock....
DeleteThey took an alarm clock - the police and insurance kept asking "What kind of clock was it? Some antique? Something special?" and I had to say "No, it was plastic.. It was the cheapest one I could find when I was travelling and needed to wake up for a flight" Hehehe (pre phone days of course...)
DeleteWhat an interesting read! I have never thought about that difference of how it is different in different countries. I've lived in France, Mexico and the US and I feel like things are similar in all 3 countries. Things weren't bad when I lived in Mexico city but I heard crime really shot up after we moved.
ReplyDeletewww.chezmireillefashiontravelmom.com
I think it's just really noticeable in Japan.
Delete